In our article Easy Steps to Better Vacation Photos, we showed the High Dynamic Range (HDR) newbie how to use Corel's Paint Shop Pro Photo X2 to easily improve vacation photos. In the slideshow tutorial, you'll notice a couple of things missing, such as a HDR save option, and a Tonemapper that seems somehow lacking in a ton of sliders. Compared to Dynamic Photo HDR, with its amazing set of HDR adjustment tools, can the experienced HDR imager be happy with two simple sliders and no 32-bit save?
Is this even real HDR, or is it rather some sort of low-bit averaging or blending wrapped up in trendy language pretending to be HDR?
Absolutely not! Corel's Paint Shop Pro Photo X2 is a powerful, intuitive Tonemapper wrapped in an ultra-simple package. I pried some information from senior Corel developers and they've done their homework.
The Merge to HDR function combines the exposures based on an EXIF rip with floating point numbers to create a true HDR image. However, the raw HDR is always in the background. It skips the HDR preview step and jumps right to the default Tonemapper preview, which simplifies the workflow for the newbie. It's a little frustrating to not be able to save in Radiance or OpenEXR format, but we'll get to that later.
"Brightness" combines gamma and exposure, along with some proprietary curve tweaks, while "Clarify" is a very impressive Local Operator which, even pushed to the max, has great photorealistic detailing without excessive haloing even along extreme edges. It is really quite advanced, moreso considering that this is Corel's first jump into HDR programming.
But it shouldn't be their last. They've got a great beginner's workflow here, with an awesome Tonemapper that's simple to use, but we want more!
We want Corel to package this Tonemapper in a standalone program. We want the ultra-simple Tonemapper, but we also want more control. We want a power-user option to be able to mess around with more sliders and different Tonemapper settings, even if the default settings are right-on!
We want the ability to save our true HDR images in OpenEXR and Radiance format, but more than that, we want to run our existing HDR images through this Tonemapper and skip the Merge to HDR step.
We want more! We'd love to see Corel take their HDR processing to the next level -- keep this super-easy version in Paint Shop Pro Photo X2, but flesh out the HDR features a bit more and make a free-standing HDR-specific program.
They've got some great things going on here: Time Tolerance quickly picks all the shots in an AEB burst with one click, a powerful Local Operator that doesn't introduce color shifts and minimizes halos, even at maximum settings, and a nice, clean design.
It would need some work: Images should be auto-rotated prior to HDR Merge. The Tonemap preview window needs to be larger. There needs to be an option to open and save 32-bit file types. The Tonemapper(s) should have "easy" and "advanced" settings. I say Tonemapper(s) because even though their Local Operator is excellent, there are times when a global operator will yield the best results, especially when the intent is to do more tweaks in low-bit space. (And we'd love to see a Mac version, too!)
We hope Corel will listen and really jump into the HDR game for the power users, because they've made a great first step.