PopPhoto.com -- The online home of American Photo and Popular Photography & Imaging

Free Newsletter: Camera reviews,
lens tests, photo news and more!
July 18, 2008
Search

Subscribe

Popular Photography American Photo
Subscriptions/Customer ServiceDigital Subscription
Give a GiftRenew My Subscription

< Previous ArticleMore Scanners Articles (14 of 18)Next Article >
Printer Friendly Send to a Friend

Top Ten Flatbed Scanners Tested


February 2001


AGFA SNAPSCAN e50

The e50 uses a USB port for hot-swappable connectivity to PC or Mac computers. The wire hanging down powers the transparency adapter built into the center of the lid.
SPECIFICATIONS: Price: $199(srp). Resolution: 1200x2400 ppi optical; 9600 ppi interpolated. Color bit depth: 42-bit color. D-range limit: <1.9 D-max. Maximum scan size: 8.5x11.7 in. Scan speed (8x10): 14 sec preview, 1min 26 sec for 300 ppi scan. Connector: USB. Film adapter: Yes; built-in transparency module w/two templates. Dimensions: 19.7x13.3x3.7 inches. Compatibility: WIN 98, 2000, Mac OS 8.0 or later. Bundled software: Agfa ScanWise, Corel PrintOffice 2000, ReadIris (OCR). Phone/web address: 800-TRY-AGFA/www.agfahome.com.

TEST RESULTS: Color Accuracy: Excellent (Overall Delta E: 7.2, best 90%: 5.4, worst 10%: 23.0). Shadow Detail: Below normal. Highlight Detail: High. Image Quality Rating: High. Speed: Fairly Slow.

FEATURES & COMMENTS: According to Agfa the reason this scanner is called "e50" is that the "e" stands for easy. That term definitely applies to the set-up software, which features a multimedia installation with sound effects. It features a 42-bit color depth and high resolution, along with a built-in transparency module and four programmable buttons for ease-of-use. The SnapScan e50 scans originals and automatically formats them for the Internet, word processing, text conversion (OCR), or image-manipulation programs. The four quick-pick buttons are located at the front of the scanner for easy access.

The ScanWise software bundled with the scanner helps simplify the scanning process. If you want, it will automatically determine the optimum settings for each application based on the photo in the scanner and the button pushed. If the user wants to attach a photograph to an e-mail, they just have to select the e-mail application as a final destination, and ScanWise will automatically set the RGB color mode and screen resolution. Then it opens the e-mail and pastes the image directly into it. ScanWise does provide manual override settings and actually offers some powerful controls when the user delves deeper.

Advanced features include compatibility with ColorSync and ICM 2.0 color management systems, and the choice of whether or not to embed scanner color profiles in the image file. However, this scanner's lower D-range limit its ability to capture maximum detail in shadows.

CANON N1220U
This unique scanner uses a single USB port for power and connectivity to PC and Mac computers. USB is about 10X faster than older parallel or serial connections.
SPECIFICATIONS: Price: $199(sp). Resolution: 1200x2400 ppi optical, 9600 ppi interpolated. Color bit depth: 42-bit internal/24-bit external. D-range limit: NA. Maximum scan size: 8.5x11.7 in. Scan speed (8x10): 15 sec preview, 53 sec for 300 ppi scan. Connector: USB. Film adapter: none. Dimensions: 10x14.7x1.3 in. Compatibility: WIN 98, 2000, Mac OS 8.5 or later. Bundled software: Canon Creative Image, includes Adobe PhotoShop 5.0 LE, Arcsoft PhotoStudio 2000, Caere OmniPage, ArcSoft PhotoBase, Acrobat reader 4.0, ScanGear Toolbox, CanoScantoolbox. Phone/web address: 800-OK-CANON/www.ccsi.canon.com.

TEST RESULTS: Color Accuracy: Extremely high (Overall Delta E: 8.2, best 90%: 6.8, worst 10%: 20.5). Shadow Detail: High. Highlight Detail: Normal. Image Quality Rating: High. Speed: Fast.

FEATURES & COMMENTS: The CanoScan N1220U is an ultra-slim (1.3-inch high) scanner with a great set of features, including Z-lid technology, which lets you raise the scan lid so that you can easily fit thicker objects on the scan bed. Its high-tech silver finish is sure to impress anyone and looks incredibly stylish either sitting on your desk, or stored away on its side in between your monitor and computer. Weighing in at only 3.3 lbs, this is the ideal traveling companion for laptop users.

The CanoScan's external one-touch button immediately starts the scanning process in 42-bit color mode (although it only saves image files in 24-bit color). We found the scanner to be extremely accurate in its color reproduction, especially when using the ColorSync mode (color accuracy is lower in both standard color correction and no correction modes). And the software bundle that ships with the N1220U is a real value. However, overall image quality suffered from slightly blown?out highlights and moderately high contrast, and the scanner was a bit noisier than most of the units tested.


Top Ten Flatbed Scanners Tested
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 Next


RELATED ARTICLES
Microtek ArtixScan M1: Review
Microtek Ships ArtixScan M1, Announces ArtixScan M1 Pro
Editors Choice 2007: Scanners
Which Scanner Should I Buy?
Scanning Film Made Easy


Search




Click to compare prices on photo equipment:


Newsletter Promo Button
Digital Days Promo Button
American Photo On Campus
Mentor Series Promo Button