Lens Test: 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6G VR AF-S DX Nikkor

PopPhoto.com
Reviews
Lenses
Lens Test: 18-55mm f/3...

Upgrade your glass to Vibration Reduction without getting rattled by the price.

By Julia Silber Posted May 14, 2008

Gallery Preview

Nikon offers tyros an option to upgrade to Vibration Reduction technology at a very nice price ($199, street) with this digital-only (DX) kit lens. A 27-82.5mm equivalent, this 3X zoom also sports a near-silent SWM focusing motor.

HANDS ON

About 2 ounces heavier (and $80 more) than the non-VR Nikkor kit lens, this upgrade is still light and amazingly compact (it casts no shadow when used with the D60's built-in flash, see the Nikon D60 camera test). Finished in a faint crinkle texture, the barrel, including lensmount, is plastic. The outer barrel rotates during focus, making it unsuitable for some filters and filter-mounting systems.

The autofocus is fast, accurate, and, thanks to the SWM motor, very quiet. The zoom ring is rubber-clad; the focusing ring is not. With a uniform drag, the MF ring turns somewhat loosely, with a relatively tight radius for fast, if coarse, focusing. The well-damped zoom ring also turns evenly.

IN THE LAB

Sharpness and contrast are in the Excellent range. Our SQF results closely match those of both the non-VR Nikkor and Canon's comparable 18-55mm IS kit zoom. DxO Analyzer 3.0.1 tests found Visible barrel distortion at 18mm (0.48%), Imperceptible barrel distortion at 35mm (0.02%), and Imperceptible pincushion distortion at 55mm (0.04%). These numbers far surpass those of Nikon's 4-year-old non-VR kit zoom, which at 18mm showed Noticeable barreling (1.30%).

Light falloff was gone by f/4.5 at 18mm, and by f/6.3 at 35mm and 55mm -- again, very favorable numbers. The comparable Canon>, for instance, showed vignetting until f/8 at 18mm. The maximum magnification ratio at the uniform close-focusing distance of about 9.5 inches ranged from 1:7.13 at 18mm to 1:2.48 at 55mm -- far better than Nikon's published spec of 1:3.2.

In tests of the Vibration Reduction system by three different users, we found sharpness gains of 1.5 to 3 stops.

CONCLUSIONS

Especially at longer focal lengths, distortion performance is better than that of many pro lenses in its zoom range. It's also superior to Nikon's earlier non-VR kit zoom by almost every metric. Whether you're new to Nikon or looking for an optical upgrade, the $80 extra for VR will be money very well spent.

Specifications

18-55mm (18.59-54.65mm tested), f/3.5-5.6 (f/3.50-5.94 tested), 11 elements in 8 groups. Focusing turns 60 degrees clockwise. Zoom ring turns 110 degrees counterclockwise. Focal lengths marked at 18-, 24-, 35-, 45-, and 55mm.

• Diagonal view angle: 76-28 degrees.

• Weight: 9.6 oz.

• Filter size: 52mm.

• Mounts: Nikon DX AF.

• Street price: $199.

  • Print Page Print
  • Stumble Upon Stumble It

Comments

Be the first to comment!

Post a Comment

Comments will not be posted until they are approved.

Visit other Bonnier sites: